Thursday, July 14, 2011

Chained CPI explained by Kevin Drum

The Chained CPI is a really bad deal for Social Security beneficiaries. Here's Kevin Drum's explanation.:
Economists on both left and right mostly agree that the current standard measure of inflation, CPI-W, slightly overstates the actual growth in the cost of living. The reason is something called "upper level substitution bias," which means that instead of always buying a standard basket of goods and services, people change their buying habits over time as prices change. When the price of hamburger goes up, they eat more chicken. When the price of chicken goes up, they switch back to hamburger.

A version of CPI that takes this into account is called chained CPI, and overall it's considered a more accurate reflection of actual inflation.
But that is actual inflation for everyone. Older people on fixed incomes are effected quite differently from most people being effected by inflation.
Initial Social Security benefits upon retirement are calculated based on wage levels, so they'd be unaffected by a switch to chained CPI. But annual COLA increases would be affected, and they'd be lower than they are now. Michael Hiltzik suggests two reasons this is unfair. First:

It's not at all certain that elderly persons on fixed incomes can make the sort of lifestyle changes contemplated by the chained CPI....That's because a larger portion of seniors' spending is concentrated in medical goods and services, which aren't as amenable to substitution as, say, oranges for apples.

....Indeed, the BLS has recognized that elderly consumers are a special case by developing an experimental CPI, known as the CPI-E, just for those 62 and older. Among other differences, the index overweights medical care as a factor in seniors' spending....The CPI-E rose nearly 7% faster than the standard CPI from 1998 through 2009, according to government estimates. It also tells you why, from the standpoint of seniors' real cost of living, the chained CPI is a rip-off.

No measure of CPI is perfect for everyone: if the price of gasoline is skyrocketing and you have a long commute, then your personal cost of living will rise faster than official inflation figures. Likewise, because healthcare costs are rising faster than most other goods, people with a lot of medical problems face higher inflation than those who are healthier. From a statistical point of view, then, the best you can do is choose a measure of CPI that's most accurate in general.

Still, the CPI-E issue is a serious objection: it applies to a very large group, and it applies to a large group that typically has modest incomes. Ideally, it would be handled by broadening the scope of Medicare, not by deliberately using an innacurate measure of general inflation, but broadening the scope of Medicare is hardly on the table right now. Given that reality, the net result of this change would be to cut Social Security benefits by calculating inflation less accurately for seniors.
The chained CPI is not representative of the income and expenses of people on Social Security. Essentially it is a cut in benefits to people generally who have no way of adjusting for the cut. It is also not needed since Social Security is not in any near term threat of financial shortage. The chained CPI is a solution looking for a problem to solve and it hasn't found it.

Labels: , ,

Saturday, December 04, 2010

Social Security Retirees expected to bail out profligate American plutocrats

The elites - the plutocrats practicing class war against the working and middle class - are after Social Security because it's a way of taxing the lower classes and handing off the money to the wealthy.

in 2000 Clinton had the deficit under control. Then Bush was selected to support a Republican House and Republican Senate. With the Presidency and Congress in their control the Republicans gave us two unsustainable tax cuts almost entirely for the rich plutocrats Bush represented. Then the bunch of them passed the prescription drug bill - with doughnut hole and without financing it. Then we got two unnecessary wars. The feds stripped the resources from Afghanistan after appearing to win it for the entirely unnecessary war in Iraq. Running military contractors has always been a way for the American rich to get much richer. (See Kevin Phillips - Wealth and Democracy.)

Add to these forms of straight up theft there was the libertarian idiocy that started seriously with Reagan and was then pushed by the Republicans plus Greenspan so that the world-wide economy went into the predictable Great Recession in 2008. So what does that have to do with Social Security?

Social Security retirement is entirely funded by the FICA tax on up to $106,000 per year in employment earnings. The working and lower middle class pay that. The plutocrats live on investments and fees, so they do not pay the FICA tax. As Social Security is it will not run out of money ever. It ispay as you go and is funded by the FICA tax. True, in 2037 the worst case scenario suggests that benefits might have to be reduced - at most by 27%. That is extremely unlikely. The SS retirement has never reached any one of its worst case scenario cases. Never. Social Security has not ever and by law can never add to the federal deficit. But it presents a big pot of accumulated money for the plutocrats to steal.

The tax cuts went to the wealthy plutocrats. They get their money from investments instead of wages and they do not pay FICA tax. Wars are fought because the plutocrats want to fight them, not because they are needed for the working and lower middle class. No one in the Middle East needs the wars being fought there except the elites. The American elites make big profits and gain political power. The Middle Eastern elites determine who will run their countries and gain power, along with the wealth the power brings them. No one gives a damned about the working or middle classes or the soldiers who are fighting those wars.

Then to, Social Security has been collecting more than it needed to since 1983. The extra funds were loaned to the federal government to pay for the excessive tax cuts for the wealthy and for the unnecessary wars. Then money from Social Security has been loaned by the trust funds to the poorly run federal government in addition to the money loaned by China. But the SS system is going to start cashing those bonds in 2012 as the baby boomers the excess FICA funds were collected for start being required. The federal government will either have to pay for the money it wasted on tax cuts and wars or it will default on federal bonds. Those bonds are the safest investment in the world right now. The feds can't default to China or the Middle Eastern oil Sheiks without massive world-wide financial problems like Argentina some years ago. Those problems would lower the wealth of the wealthy plutocrats like Pete Peterson. They might have to pay higher taxes to pay for the money the elites have been wasting for the last decade.

But if the elites can force workers to work longer and take lower retirement benefits, the elites will never have to pay the Social Security System back. America avoids the default and the elite plutocrats don't have to pay for the money they have been directing the federal government to give to them. Also, their wealth will not be in dangers since America will not be recognized as defaulting on its bonds - even though pulling the funds out of the SS Trust funds without ever repaying it is in fact a default.

Folks, this isn't sharing the pain. This is theft from the working people of America. The rich are stealing from the poor and working class. Reverse Robin Hood. That's all it is.

Paul Krugman has an interesting view on the current efforts to destroy cut Social Security.
Social Security [...] is something that matters enormously to the bottom half of the income distribution, but no[t] so much to people in the 250K-plus club. A 30 percent cut in benefits would represent disaster for tens of millions of Americans, but a barely noticeable inconvenience for VSPs and everyone they know. A rise in the retirement age would be a vast hardship for people who do manual labor, but if anything a gift to VSPs, who don’t want to step aside in any case. And so on down the line.

So going after Social Security is a way to seem tough and serious — but entirely at the expense of people you don’t know.



Addendum
The deficit hysteria which is being inflicted on America as though this was an unneeded war is designed solely to justify the attack on Social Security.

You will notice above that Social Security is fully paid through all its past history and continues to be fully funded into the reasonably foreseeable future. Even 27 years into the future (NOT reasonably predictable at this time) given the very unlikely worst case scenario Social Security retirement will not contribute to the deficit at all. By law Social Security Retirement can never be deficit funded.

If the problem is the deficit, then the solution has to be found in taxing the wealthy for the services they demand (wars) and in controlling health care costs. Notice that health care costs are not considered by the catfood commission or by the media. That's the proof that no one is serious about reducing the deficit and that this is all intended as an attack on the Social Security system.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, October 06, 2010

The Truth about Social Security

When you are surrounded by lies and demagoguery, where do you go to find the truth? Try Paul N. Van de Water if the lies involve Social Security.
In a new paper, I’ve tried to correct some of the misinformation that critics of Social Security have been spreading about the program.

Here are the facts. Social Security is a well-run, fiscally responsible program. People earn retirement, survivors, and disability benefits by making payroll tax contributions during their working years. Those taxes and other revenues are deposited in the Social Security trust funds, and all benefits and administrative expenses are paid out of the trust funds. The amount that Social Security can spend is limited by its payroll tax income plus the balance in the trust funds.

The Social Security trustees — the official body charged with evaluating the program’s long-term finances — project that Social Security can pay 100 percent of promised benefits through 2037 and about three-quarters of scheduled benefits after that, even if Congress makes no changes in the program. Relatively modest changes would put the program on a sound financial footing for 75 years and beyond.

Nonetheless, some critics are attempting to undermine confidence in Social Security with wild and blatantly false accusations. They allege that the trust funds have been “raided” or disparage the trust funds as “funny money” or mere “IOUs.” Some even label Social Security a “Ponzi scheme” after the notorious 1920s swindler Charles Ponzi. All of these claims are nonsense.

Every year since 1984, Social Security has collected more in payroll taxes and other income than it pays in benefits and other expenses. (The authors of the 1983 Social Security reform law did this on purpose in order to help pre-fund some of the costs of the baby boomers’ retirement.) These surpluses are invested in U.S. Treasury securities that are every bit as sound as the U.S. government securities held by investors around the globe; investors regard these securities as among the world’s very safest investments.

Investing the trust funds in Treasury securities is perfectly appropriate. The federal government borrows funds from Social Security to help finance its ongoing operations in the same way that consumers and businesses borrow money deposited in a bank to finance their spending. In neither case does this represent a “raid” on the funds. The bank depositor will get his or her money back when needed, and so will the Social Security trust funds.

As far back as 1938, independent advisors to Social Security firmly endorsed the investment of Social Security surpluses in Treasury securities, saying that it does “not involve any misuse of these moneys or endanger the safety of these funds.”

Moreover, Social Security is the “polar opposite of a Ponzi scheme,” says the man who quite literally wrote the book about Ponzi’s famous scam, Boston University professor Mitchell Zuckoff. The Social Security Administration’s historian has a piece on this topic as well.

Unlike the frauds of Ponzi — and, more recently, Bernard Madoff — Social Security does not promise unrealistically large financial returns and does not require unsustainable increases in the number of participants to remain solvent. Instead, for the past 75 years it has provided a foundation that workers can build on for retirement as well as social insurance protection to families whose breadwinner dies and workers who become disabled.


[H/T to Digby.]

Labels:

Thursday, February 22, 2007

Vilsack proposes indexing Social Security to prices not wages

Former Iowa Governor Tom Vilsack, running for the Republican nomination for President, has just proposed that Social Security should be indexed to prices rather than to wages.

Wages increase more than prices do. What indexing SS behefits to prices rather than wages will do is slowly lower benefits for everyone on Social Security, while lowering benefits for higher wage-earners more than for lower wage-earners. The result is that everyone gets lower benefits, and in about 80 years, high and low wage-earners will all be receiving the same amount in benefits. For all beneficiaries the benefits received will replace a lot less of their preretirement earnings than is currently the case.

For a very good explanation, go over to Eschaton and follow the links.

This is another Republican proposal designed to subtly destroy the Social Security program.

Labels: ,